Monthly Archives: May 2022

Announcement: Send Us Your Guest Nominations for “Who Are You?”



We are seeking guest nominations for an experimental subseries, titled “Who Are You?”

Listeners to the Jim Rutt Show will know that one of its hallmarks is Jim’s extensive preparation for interviews. Guests on the show are people he already knows about, and generally he’s familiar with their work before he invites them on.

“Who Are You?” will reverse all that. In these interviews, Jim won’t know who the guest is or what they want to talk about prior to showtime. Not a clue! That’s why he’ll begin with the question: Who Are You?

Guests will need to be prepared to start from ground zero—to explain who they are, what they do, and why anyone should care. Jim will need to be prepared to adapt on the fly to what he hears and to steer the conversation in a direction he and the audience can learn from.

Once nominations are in, we’ll select a subset of reasonable options and list them in a poll, to be shared on this site and all of our social media feeds. (Luckily, Jim is on a break from social media and won’t see the posts or any discussion about them. You of course should not inform Jim about any of the nominations during this process.)

Please see the guidelines below, and send your nomination to nominations@jimruttshow.com by this Friday (5/20), midnight ET. Note the brief window and act quickly.

Nomination Guidelines:

Limit of one nomination per person. You may nominate yourself. Please limit nominations to people who:

  • Are doing, saying, or working toward something you consider interesting and useful enough to warrant Jim and his audience’s attention—or, who you just think it’d be entertaining to throw into conversation with Jim.
  • Would conceivably want to come on the show.
  • Jim does not know or know of as far as you’re aware. (We’ll run a search for any likely connections as we narrow down options.)
  • Exist and are human.

*** If possible, please provide an email address for your nominee, and notify them that you’ve put their name in.

Says Jim: “This is an experiment and may fail, but it ought to be good for a laugh, if nothing else.”

If it’s successful, we may choose to launch “Who Are You?” as an ongoing subseries on the Jim Rutt Show.

Again, send nominations to nominations@jimruttshow.com by this Friday (5/20), midnight ET.


EP 157 Terrence Deacon on Mind’s Emergence From Matter



Jim talks to Terrence Deacon about the ideas in his book Incomplete Nature: How Mind Emerged From Matter. They discuss the story of zero, integrating absence into physical theories, systems that generate entropy to stave off entropy, the history of emergence & the risk of mysterianism, reframing emergence as removal & constraint, orthograde vs contragrade processes, 3 layers of emergence, the special case of end-directed (teleodynamic) processes, a simple model of autogenesis, contrasting & integrating Shannon, Boltzmann, and Bateson, moving toward sentience, nested teleodynamic processes, feeling as primary to consciousness, rethinking the nervous system in non-computational terms, consciousness as a self-undoing process, inverting the hard problem, and much more.

Professor Terrence W. Deacon has held faculty positions at Harvard University, Harvard Medical School, Boston University, and the University of California, Berkeley. His laboratory research has combined human evolutionary biology and neuroscience, with the aim of investigating the evolution of human cognition. This work extends from cellular-molecular neurobiology and cross-species fetal neural transplantation to the study of semiotic processes underlying animal and human communication, especially language. These topics are explored in his 1997 book, The Symbolic Species: The Coevolution of Language and the Brain. Currently, his theoretical interests have focused on the problem of explaining emergent phenomena, in such unprecedented transitions as the origin of life, the evolution of language, and the generation of conscious experience by brains. His 2012 book, Incomplete Nature: How Mind Emerged from Matter, explores how the interrelationships between thermodynamic, self-organizing, evolutionary, and semiotic processes are implicated in the production of these emergent transitions.


EP 156 James Poulos on Remaining Human



Jim talks with James Poulos about the ideas in his new book Human Forever: The Spiritual Politics of Digital War. They discuss his decision to publish the book on the blockchain, going beginner’s-mind on media & communications theory, the meaning of Gnosticism, responsibility as worship & its transfer to machines, returning worth to the human, a short introduction to Marshall McLuhan, raising the first fully digital generation, expert engineers vs ethereal ethicists, “peak woke” & the collapse of wokeness, religion as “the only permanent state of mankind,” resisting the temptation to call down apocalypse, the hubris of messiah-hood, Hebraic British Protestant theology & its incongruence with American civilization, how queerness & transgender identity became culturally dominant, the left’s abandonment of liberalism for a new post-human religion, differentiating transhumanism & human-maxing, and much more.
James Poulos creates and advises brands and ventures at the intersection of technology, media, and design. He is the Cofounder and Editor of The American Mind at the Claremont Institute and the Founder and Publisher of RETURN at New Founding. He is the author of Human, Forever and The Art of Being Free, and his writing has appeared in The Claremont Review of BooksLe FigaroNational AffairsThe New York Times, and The Washington Post, among many other publications. He lives on the edge of Los Angeles.

Currents 062: Stephanie Lepp Interviews Jim Rutt on Musk and Moderation



In this episode, Jim Rutt is a guest on his own show! He’s interviewed by Stephanie Lepp about the ideas in his Quillette essay “Musk and Moderation.” They discuss where things stand with Musk’s recent purchase of Twitter, Jim’s 41-year background in online community moderation, strengthening & clarifying Twitter’s decorum moderation, loosening point-of-view moderation, the “green sprouts” issue & the importance of tolerating fringe ideas, an appeal protocol for rulebreakers & stepping through an imagined violation by Trump, the meaning & plausibility of Twitter as a “fair and effective marketplace of ideas,” a crowd-sourced fact-checking system, defining the metrics of a thriving marketplace of ideas, whether stricter moderation is needed at the start, using theory-practice-theory loops in complex domains, Elon Musk as a potential bridge from GameA to GameB, a direct invitation to Musk, and much more.

Stephanie Lepp is a producer whose work strives to hold up a mirror — inviting us to grow from what we see. She’s the Executive Producer at the Center for Humane Technology, the organization at the heart of the Netflix documentary The Social Dilemma. Her project Deep Reckonings — a series of explicitly-marked deepfake videos that imagine morally courageous versions of our public figures — won two Webbys and has been exhibited worldwide. Deep Reckonings was also the subject of her first appearance on The Jim Rutt Show, in episode 129. Be in touch with Stephanie on Twitter: @stephlepp.